As 2011 comes to a close, we took some time to go through all of the releases for the year and give you what made our playlists this year. There really was a lot released this year, and quite a bit on tap for next year. As we were going through this we realized that for the average listener, some of these bands go unheard of, or the new release goes unnoticed. We hope that in that sense we help fill a void for those that may not have the time to get their hands on everything that’s out there, or have become casual listeners because life does get priority over everything else, and we certainly understand that.
The formats have changed but the search continues. We’ve gone from scouring tape bins and cutout racks for that elusive record that turned your world upside down, but didn’t sell enough copies at the time to warrant wide distribution. Now we scour used cd shops to find something that went missing over the years, or, after years of wear and tear…finally gave out. We certainly test the limits of the medium.
It’s been a great year for new releases. We’d like to thank record labels like Frontiers, Nuclear Blast, Roadrunner and Kivel records for bringing us some of the best new hard rock and metal this year. And it’s not that the major “mainstream” labels didn’t help a bit, it’s just that these labels really cater to our crowd. Thanks goes out to Rock Candy Records for taking the time to put those hard to find releases back in distribution so that a new generation of kids can understand what really good hard rock is…and it allows us old guys to fill the holes in our collections because we wore out the tape!...Special kudos to Michael McPherson at NEH Records, the best place to shop in the US for new and re-released melodic hard rock and metal.
So…what a year… we’ve had the return of a lot of bands, some line-up changes, and some new artists break through as well. Melodic hard rock and heavy metal is out there… you just have to look for it…
Without further ado… here is our top 10’s for 2011. We don’t always agree on the order, but we’re pretty consistent on what we think was the best this year [In our not so humble opinions…].
Starting at number 10…
Stefan: Kimball/Jamison- Self-Titled: “When two powerhouse vocalists like Jimi Jamison and Bobby Kimball team up, the results are, of course, amazing. Kimball/Jamison is packed full of hooks, harmonies and deep lyrics. This is definitely recommended for fans of straightforward melodic rock.”
Finster: Symphony X – Iconoclast: “Machines taking over man…Epic, technically amazing, bombastic, melodic, orchestral, and hands down one of the best releases of the year. The interplay of guitarist Michael Romeo and keyboardist Mike Pinnella is a highlight of this record. A progressive metal masterpiece…they sound awesome… Russell Allen goes from melodic to aggressive and back… A definite winner…”
Number 9...
Stefan: Chickenfoot - III - "Skipping right over the angst that goes with making the follow-up album to a successful debut, Chickenfoot simply named their second album Chickenfoot III. Clever! These guys sure know how to write serious rock tunes and kick some ass while doing so. Sammy Hagar's distinct voice and Satriani's guitar magic are a perfect blend on top of Michael Anthony's huge bass lines and big backing vocals. Chad Smith's drumming is certainly nothing to sneeze at either!"
Finster: Anthrax – Worship Music: “Marking the return of vocalist Joey Belladonna, and their first new release in 8 years, this album has it all… the riffs, the power, the songwriting…everything that makes Anthrax one of the Big 4. Excellent”
Number 8...
Stefan: Megadeth – Th1rt3en: “Th1rt3en marks the return of Dave Ellefson, and the timing couldn’t be better. Megadeth consistenly puts out heavy, aggressive metal tunes album after album, and the writing continues to progress for this quarter of The Big 4. This album should be the latest addition to any Megadeth fan’s collection.”
Finster: Chickenfoot – III: “I have been a fan of Hagar from Montrose, solo, HSAS, and Van Halen, so add the technical prowess of Joe Satriani, and the rhythm section of Michael Anthony and Chad Smith, and this is a no brainer for me. They just want to play outstanding rock and roll and have a great time doing it. They succeed on both levels here…”
Number 7...
Stefan: Anthrax – Worship Music: “Alex, what is bringing back Joey Belladonna? The answer is: the smartest thing Anthrax has done in years. An excellent release from another quarter of The Big 4. In my opinion, this could be their best release to-date.”
Finster: Megadeth – Th1rt3en: “I took some time this year to devour the Megadeth catalog [courtesy of Stefan who filled the gaps…thanks!...] before this came out, and my expectations were matched and then some. Bassist Dave Ellefson returned and he and Shawn Drover really keep the rhythm section moving, while the interplay with Dave Mustaine is as tight as ever. There is not a bad song on the record, and Dave Mustaine has been quoted as saying this is one of his best works…I have to agree…”
Number 6...
Stefan: Whitesnake – Forevermore: “David Coverdale has brought the band to the next level … AGAIN. Doug Aldrich’s shredding yet melodic guitar licks bring Coverdale’s lyrics to life. Forevermore yet again delivers the classic yet current hard rock sound we expect to hear from the legend himself.”
Finster: Whitesnake – Forevermore: “Building on the last record “Good To Be Bad”, I feel they really came out stronger on this release. This was the 2nd full release with the writing team of Coverdale/Aldrich, and the album gels all the way through. It doesn’t hurt when you throw Reb Beach and Brian Tichy into the mix either. Strong songs, anthems, guitar solos, power ballads…all the things you’ve come to expect from a Whitesnake record, and done with precision. Add to that Coverdale was 60 when he recorded it, and while his voice has aged over time, he more than makes up for it in his energy and passion…”
Number 5...
Stefan: Mr. Big – What If: “It was really hard placing Mr. Big’s What If at #5 on my list. It goes to show you how great of a release year it was! LOL! Seriously though, what a great return for these guys. Mr. Big has always been a musician’s band, i.e. the guys are all top notch musicians. On their 2011 tour, this was evident when the guys all switched instruments and began jamming to Deep Purple’s Smoke On The Water for their first encore. [Side note: Mr. Big Live concert review to follow one of these days … sorry for the delay in getting this written up! Life happens …] What If brings a 21st century vibe to the definition of melodic hard rock. The guys are perfectionists and that certainly comes out in the arrangements and production of What If. However, they still know how to put on a live show with a raw feel to it … because it’s just them ripping out the tunes with no special effects.”
Finster: House Of Lords – Big Money: “From the first scream of “Money” in the opener to this record, you know right away that if you’re looking for great melodic hard rock…you’ve found it. James Christian really doesn’t seem to age and his voice just keeps getting stronger. This lineup of the band has been in place for the last few albums and they continue to sound great here. Guitarist Jimi Bell, bassist Chris McCarvill and drummer BJ Zampa shine on this record. Pick this up….”
Number 4...
Stefan: House Of Lords- Big Money: “James Christian delivers yet another stellar vocal performance. JC is like a fine wine … he gets better with age. The tunes are amazing – big hooks, big guitars, big background vocals and about the best production a band could dream about. Finster said it best … pick this one up!”
Finster: Voodoo Circle – Broken Heart Syndrome: The complete band name is Alex Beyrodt’s Voodoo Circle… Alex is the guitarist for Sinner/Silent Force and more recently, Primal Fear. He is joined by his Primal Fear band mate Matt Sinner and Pink Cream 69 vocalist David Readman. I’m a huge fan of all or their individual work, particularly Readman, so when I heard this I found myself playing it over and over. It’s an intentional throwback to Rainbow/Deep Purple/Whitesnake with Beyrodt’s incredible solos mixed in. David Readman sounds great and the band really kicks. Definitely worth a listen or two… This was their second release, so pick up the self titled debut as well…I’m holding out for another one…”
Number 3...
Stefan: Edguy – Age Of The Joker: “I’m sensing a theme here … Finster and I agreeing! Edguy was definitely an undiscovered gem for me this past year or so. Since then, I’ve picked up their entire back catalog, and it certainly doesn’t disappoint. What disappoints me is that I’ve missed seeing them live here in the United States over the last 5 years or so. Yet I digress … Age Of The Joker was a much anticipated album in 2011 for me (and I’m sure for Finster too). Edguy’s sometimes tongue-in-cheek lyrics (a la Tobias Sammet, check out track #6 called Two Out Of Seven) are present on this album too, but they are surrounded by simply incredible riffs and melodies. Age Of The Joker feels like a natural next step in Edguy’s journey through life. They have matured (and I don’t mean mature as the opposite of immature), just simply maturing into veterans of the power metal genre. From beginning to end, Edguy keeps you listening intently and wanting more.”
Finster: Edguy – Age Of The Joker: It appears we agree once again!... Being huge fans of both Edguy and Avantasia [Tobias Sammet’s other project] we had high expectations for this release, and we got it in spades. An excellent mix of power metal, hard rock, and the added touch of their humor, Edguy really came out strong after what was considered a mediocre album [Tinnitus Sanctus – which I loved]. While some have dismissed them as of late for not staying purely in the power metal vein, I credit the diversity they have created for creating a much more interesting album. Given the amount of people leader Tobias Sammet has worked with in the Avantasia project, it would be in my opinion unusual for him to not take some influences of the artists he worked with, with him. It’s great from start to finish…”
Number 2...
Stefan: Avantasia – The Flying Opera: Around The World In 20 Days – Live: “Tobias Sammet has yet again delivered an Avantasia release that captures the essence of operatic heavy metal. This time, it’s live and in your face. The 2-cd special edition comes with the entire live show on DVD as well. From Jorn Lande to Bob Catley to Kai Hansen and Amanda Somerville, Tobias rips through tune after tune with his guest vocalists. Sascha Paeth and Oliver Hartmann deliver scorching guitar rhythms and solos. Although my partner in crime Finster has a separate category for Live Releases, I felt The Flying Opera was worthy of a place on my Top 10 list of 2011. This album has gotten heavy rotation from me since the day I picked it up.”
Finster: Dream Theater – A Dramatic Turn Of Events: Given the amount of press this band got for the departure of founding member and drummer Mike Portnoy, interest in this record was at peak at the time of its release. The band had already released an excellent video documentary on choosing Pornoy’s replacement [ex Steve Vai/Extreme drummer Mike Mangini – a monster on the kit…] and really made sure the PR void left by Portnoy was filled. So...after all this… how is it?… It’s the Dream Theater I began to follow when I first heard When Dream And Day Unite and then Images And Words. It’s definitely metal, but with a pronounced progressive edge to it. After Six Degrees they got darker, and heavier, decidedly so on Train Of Thought, but they seemed to have stayed there for the next few releases, and at times seemed to follow the trend instead of setting it. Jordan Rudess’ keys are back as an excellent counterpart to John Petrucci’s amazing guitar. It’s a much brighter album, with multiple touches of the other band member’s influences, as well as the welcome return of James LaBrie’s and John Myung’s songwriting. This is the kind of album you may not initially warm up to [It took me a while and I’m a huge fan], but after listening to it and delving deeper into the record, I consider it one of their best. Give it a listen, you won’t be disappointed…
[I must also make an editorial comment…when we started putting this together, I put live albums separately, as you will see… I consider Avantasia’s “The Flying Opera” hands down the best live release of the year…I just separated it out before we converged on the writing of this… so it’s in Stefan’s top 10, but not mine…thanks…]
And Our Number 1's For 2011...
Stefan: Sixx A.M. – This Is Gonna Hurt: “Nikki Sixx comes back with a vengeance, writing an album that tells the story of his life through his lyrics. It’s raw, yet polished, edgy, yet smooth. James Michael delivers the message of each song with amazing passion and emotion that you think he’s singing about himself. Michael steps in front of the mike (not typical of this famed rock producer) and provides exactly the edge Nikki’s songs need. I was hooked upon the first 10 seconds of this album, when the pounding kick drum begins thumping and the guitar starts crunching on a low D. This Is Gonna Hurt, track #1 and the title track, hits an energy level of 100 (on a scale of 10) from the first note Michael sings. I honestly don’t know how Nikki can top himself on the next album, assuming there will be one. Although these songs stray from the typical Motley Crue sound, it is an absolute crime for any Crue fan (or rock fan for that matter!) to not add this album to their collection.”
Finster: Mr. Big – What If: When I heard the line-up of Mr. Big was reforming for a new full length release [They recorded 2 tracks for their “Return To Budokan” live record…] I was really looking forward to this release. I am a huge fan of all the material, including the records with Ritchie Kotzen, who may have steered them in a more blues direction, but the output was still excellent. So…what we have here is one of the most solid releases of the year. From the first track “Undertow” they come out swinging and you can tell the energy and technical precision that has marked all their albums has returned. The production has a more modern feel to it, but the trademark sound of the band is still intact and the whole record sounds solid from start to finish. The interplay of Paul Gilbert and Billy Sheehan really comes out on this record, most prominently on “Around The World”. Overall it’s an album that really hits you from start to finish. Given the animosity and acrimony when these guys finally called it quits, it’s refreshing to see they were able to pick up where they left off with class and style, and they really sound like they are enjoying themselves… “
2011 Honorable Mention:
Which ones were almost there but didn’t make either list?… here are a few of the best releases of the year, and if we did a top 20 they would sit squarely in it… [in our not so humble opinion…]
Stefan: Sebastian Bach/Night Ranger/Stryper – – “Sebastian Bach came kicking and screaming back into 2011 with his latest release … yep, you guessed it – Kicking And Screaming! Sebastian doesn’t disappoint with as strong a vocal performance as we’ve heard from him in years. Add 20 year old guitar prodigy Nick Sterling to the mix and you have a solid metal album full of raw power. Night Ranger, veterans to the rock scene, released Somewhere In California this year. This is their 10th studio album, and it contains some great mid-tempo rockers and some more modern-sounding tunes, but overall a pleasure to listen to. Stryper put their own spin on some rock classics this year when they released The Covering. From the Scorpions and Kiss to Maiden, Priest and Sabbath (yes, Sabbath!), Michael Sweet and the guys rip through these tunes like they’ve been playing them for years – and play them very well! All three of these albums are also worth picking up. Let’s face it, we’ve had a kick ass year for new music! Let’s hope 2012 is just as good!
Finster: Adrenaline Mob/Beggars & Thieves/Queensryche – “An EP, a return of an underrated band, and Queensryche?...you’re thinking…what was he thinking… how about this… The Adrenaline Mob EP is just a taste of what’s to come from this new project featuring Mike Portnoy from Dream Theater and Russell Allen from Symphony X. It’s heavy, loud and dark, and the performances are amazing. Beggars & Thieves is a favorite of mine since the debut. These guys kept going no matter what the odds, so it’s refreshing to see that Frontiers Records picked them up and they put together a great record. Take a chance and give it a listen. Now Queensryche is a bone of contention with a lot of fans. I have to point out that while everyone wanted another Operation:Mindcrime [and Mindcrime II didn’t live up to the hype...] or Empire…this band continued to expand and update and change their sound over the years. Right after Empire, we got Promised Land…and everyone collectively shook their heads…but it’s a great record. Change is good. This is more modern sounding, and less heavy…but you can’t mistake Geoff Tate’s vocals. If you’re stuck on Queensryche circa 1989, I’m not going to change your mind…but if you’re looking to hear a different type of hard rock record, pick this up…”
Don’t forget we also had great releases[in no particular order] by HammerFall, Eden’s Curse, Out Loud, Ten, Scheepers, Work Of Art, King Kobra, Black ‘N’ Blue, Warrant, Borealis, Within Temptation, Black Country Communion, Far Cry, Shy, Issa, Fergie Frederiksen, Trilium, Mecca, Derek Sherinian, Tony MacAlpine, Michael Schenker, and probably a few we forgot…
In The Live Album Category…
Avantasia – The Flying Opera: Around The World In 20 Days – Live: In our opinion Avantasia really captured the moment on their 2007 tour for the release of the album “The Scarecrow”. They pulled out all the stops and really made a night worth remembering. If you have a chance to see the dvd…it’s definitely worth the price of admission!... 1 CD/ DVD
Doro – 25 Years In Rock: A live set celebrating one of the best female voices in rock ever. In a business dominated by guys…she made her mark with Warlock and never gave up. An excellent document of an outstanding career… 2 DVD/1 CD
Slash live with Myles Kennedy on vocals is killer, and Slash shows why G’NR is where it is without him. Kennedy takes on all the era’s of Slash’s career and makes them his own. Worth finding… 2 CD/DVD…
Rush – Time Machine: Live In Cleveland 2011: Not metal per se, but there’s not a band of any technical prowess that doesn’t cite these guys as influences. As hard core fans we felt it deserved to be on this list. Recorded in Cleveland, the first American city to give them airplay of the first Rush album, it’s an excellent document of another outstanding tour. While Geddy’s voice has changed over the years [and at times, admittedly are stretched to their limits], they are still playing as tight as ever. Bonus for the complete performance of the Moving Pictures album… 2 CD or DVD
Whitesnake – Live At Donington 1990: Taken from their performance at the Monsters Of Rock Festival [now called Download] at Castle Donington on August 18, 1990, and performing with the Slip Of The Tongue line-up with both Vandenberg and Vai on guitar, Rudy Sarzo and Tommy Aldridge. The performance is tight and the energy is tangible. This was heavily bootlegged so it’s always good to see a “proper” release. Coverdale takes command of the stage and holds it for the entire 1990 performance from the Donington music festival… 2 CD/DVD
Gotthard live is one of the last performances by singer Steve Lee before his tragic motorcycle accident, playing to a home crowd. You can feel the love of the home crowd as the band tears through their set… Import - 1-CD plus Region 2 DVD from a different 1999 concert…
Jorn – Live in Black is from the Spirit Black tour, and is a great performance by one of the best vocalists in rock. The set list covers Jorn’s entire career, leaning more on the newer releases. Recorded at the 2010 Sweden Rock Festival…Definitely worth seeking out… 1 CD/DVD
Deep Purple – Live In Montreux 2011: Deep Purple performs all the classics with an orchestra at the Montreux Festival on July 16, 2011. DP Mk. II alumni Ian Pace, Roger Glover and Ian Gillan are joined by the amazing Steve Morse, who took over in ’94 [after Blackmore left and was replaced for the tour by Joe Satriani], and the “new guy” on keys is none other than veteran Don Airey…who’s been in the band since ’01, taking over for a retiring Jon Lord. Gillan’s vocals have a lot in common with Geddy’s, in that time has certainly aged his voice, but after 40 years, the band is still as tight as ever and they sound like they are really enjoying themselves.. 2 CD or DVD
And finally Def Leppard – Mirrorball: Live And More… this is a good greatest hits live record…but it’s got a lot of “what if’s”…What if they covered the albums Slang, Euphoria, and X…what if they included “Let It Go” from High & Dry as a bonus track instead of “Bad Actress” from Sparkle Lounge.. Live hits, 3 new songs…overall good…could have been great…and we’re fans… 2 CD plus bonus DVD…
And since it’s always a good idea to have viable product in the market…we have some of the better compilations out there. If you’re a fan of these bands…you already have them [particularly Judas Priest, who have almost as many compilations as studio albums…] but if you’re a casual fan and just want a slice of the catalog…here are some good ways to start…
Iron Maiden: From Fear To Eternity: The Best Of 1990-2010 covers from No Prayer For The Dying up through Final Frontier. All songs originally sung by replacement singer Blaze Bayley have been replaced by live versions sung by Dickinson. Overall this is a comprehensive piece of the latter years…
Judas Priest: The Chosen Few – This compilation is a little different in that although you get a lot of the “hits” per se, you get deeper album cuts chosen by their peers, so the set list does offer something different. Choices come from Ozzy, Lemmy, Kerry King, and may other heavy metal luminaries. Not a bad mix of songs..and never a bad song on it…
Axel Rudi Pell – The Ballads IV – The title tells the tale… the fourth release of German guitar hero Pell’s softer instrumentals and ballads compiled. Again if you’re a fan you have them, if you are interested in hearing some of rocks better ballads..without having to purchase the Monster Ballads compilation…this is a good start…
Poison – Double Dose: Ultimate Hits… a little double entendre on the cover, and a two disc set of everything you will ever need from Poison unless you are a die-hard fan. Poison thanks you for contributing to their retirement once again…
And to finish up our thoughts on 2011 we have a special “What Were They Thinking” category where we would like to present our choice for the most misguided release of 2011…
Metallica/Lou Reed – Lulu… WTH guys?...really… that’s all we’ve got for this one… pick it up at your own discretion…
And we’ve got some releases on the horizon for 2012 that you might find interesting…
Coming in 2012…
Black Sabbath [Tentative 2012 release with the original line-up]
Van Halen [Alex, Eddie, Wolfie and Dave…] [Tent. Feb. release]
Mr. Big – Live From The Living Room [Feb.]
Scorpions – Comeblack [New Studio] and Get Your Sting And Blackout [Live]
Primal Fear – Unbreakable
Dokken
Sunstorm – Emotional Fire
UFO – Seven Deadly
Trixter – TBD
Nightwish – Imaginaerum [Special Edition-Jan 10]
Mollo/Martin – The Third Cage
Accept - Stalingrad
Epica – Requiem For The Indifferent
Kiss - Monster
Adrenaline Mob [Mike Portnoy, Russell Allen]
Flying Colors [Mike Portnoy, Neal Morse, Steve Morse, Dave LaRue and Casey McPherson]
Mecca – Undeniable
L.A. Guns – Lost In The City Of Los Angeles
Halestorm
Lacuna Coil – Dark Adrenaline
Keep your eyes open for more on the horizon, and keep an open mind that metal is no longer what we remember it to be, and there is a place for all of the genres and sub-genres that have developed over time… Just keep listening…
That’s a wrap…We hope that you and your families had a wonderful Holiday Season. Thank you for taking the time to be with us this year. We’ve got a lot on tap for 2012 and we’ll be back to keep up with this crazy hard rock/heavy metal scene. Just remember, support the artists, support the live shows and particularly support your local scene…that band you saw yesterday could be huge tomorrow…but they won’t do it without your support…
Until next time…
Stefan & Finster
































